When you’re up in a tree, everything changes. The view, the quiet, the entire feel of the hunt—it’s a unique experience that draws many to saddle hunting. If you’ve already read our guide "Saddle Hunting 101: Everything You Need to Get Started", you might be ready to take things to the next level with some serious gear. Two saddles that hunters often rave about are the Method 2 and the Lonestar. But which one is right for you?

Choosing the right saddle is a bit like picking hiking boots: it needs to fit well, offer support over long periods, and suit your unique style. Both the Method 2 and Lonestar have a lot to offer, but they cater to different types of hunters. Let’s break down their features, strengths, and how they might match your needs.

First, Think About Your Hunting Style

Before diving into the specifics of each saddle, it's important to think about your hunting approach. Ask yourself these questions:

• Do you prefer to stay in one spot, or move around a lot?
  Are you the kind of hunter who likes to stay in one tree all day, or do you adjust your position based on what the game is doing? If you’re always shifting positions based on movement or fresh signs, a more portable and lightweight saddle might be better suited to your needs.

• How important is comfort?
  If you spend extended periods in the tree, comfort can be critical. Some hunters are willing to sacrifice a little comfort for increased mobility, while others need a saddle that allows them to sit comfortably for hours without constantly shifting to relieve pressure points.

• Do you like customizing your gear, or do you prefer simplicity?
  Some hunters enjoy fine-tuning their gear to create a perfectly dialed-in setup, while others prefer something simple that doesn’t require much adjustment. Consider how much time you want to spend tweaking and adjusting your saddle.

Your answers to these questions will help you figure out which saddle will work best for you.

The Method 2: Lightweight and Customizable

If you’re the type of hunter who likes to move around a lot and adjust your setup, the Method 2 might be perfect for you. It’s built for hunters who prioritize mobility and stealth but don’t want to compromise too much on comfort.

Key Features of the Method 2:

• Two-Panel Design:
  The Method 2 has a flexible two-panel design that packs down to a compact 9-inch size when you’re walking, but opens up to give you plenty of support once you’re in the tree. The two-panel system allows you to adjust both the top and bottom panels independently, creating a custom fit. This feature is especially useful for longer sits, as it provides support exactly where you need it, whether it's under your thighs, lower back, or across your hips. Unlike single-panel designs, this two-panel setup reduces hot spots and pressure points, allowing for better comfort when you're perched for long periods.

• Quiet Adjustments:
  Noisy gear is a hunter’s worst enemy. The Method 2 uses magnets to silently connect and adjust its panels, so you don’t have to worry about giving away your position. These rare-earth magnets are built into the system to make quick and quiet panel deployment easy—especially useful in low-light situations or when you're trying to remain stealthy. This eliminates the need for clips or Velcro that could create unwanted noise.

• Metal-Free Design:
  Metal parts can clink and make noise, so the Method 2 ditches metal altogether. Instead, it uses a belt made from a durable rope material—UHMWPE and polyester—that lets you make quick, quiet adjustments. The absence of metal means less weight to carry, reduced noise, and no concerns about rust or freezing in cold weather. This construction prioritizes stealth and durability, keeping you undetected as you move or adjust in the tree.

• Free-Floating Belt:
  The Method 2's belt moves with you, allowing for a more natural fit as you shift your position. This floating system prevents the belt from pinching or creating unnecessary pressure, and it allows for unrestricted movement as you lean or adjust. The floating feature means that even if you’re walking or hiking to your spot, you won’t feel constricted by the saddle.

• Vertical Support Skeleton (VSS):
  This is a fancy way of saying that the saddle is designed to follow the curves of your body, providing extra support and comfort. The VSS creates vertical rigidity, giving you more structured support, especially during longer sits. By mirroring the natural contours of your body, it helps reduce fatigue and keeps you comfortable, especially when paired with the flexibility of the two-panel system.

When to Use the Method 2

Picture this: It’s early morning, and you're moving through thick brush, trying to stay undetected. The Method 2’s compact profile won’t snag on branches or slow you down. Once you find the perfect tree, you can set up quickly and adjust the panels to make sure you’re comfortable. The magnets allow for quick, silent deployment, so even in low light, you can get situated without creating noise. And if you decide to move to another spot later, packing it up is easy due to its lightweight design.

Is the Method 2 Right for You?

• You move around a lot and need lightweight gear that’s easy to pack up and go.
• You like to fine-tune your gear to get the perfect fit.
• You want a quiet, stealthy saddle that won’t make noise.

The Lonestar: Maximum Comfort for Long Sits

On the other hand, if you’re the type of hunter who prefers to pick one spot and stay there for hours, the Lonestar might be more your style. This saddle focuses on comfort, especially for hunters who spend long hours waiting in the tree.

Key Features of the Lonestar:

• Cradle Chassis:
  This design doubles the surface area that supports your body. It spreads your weight evenly, which means less pressure on any one spot, reducing fatigue. The Cradle Chassis offers superior weight distribution, which can be crucial during those long, stationary sits. Because it provides a broader base of support, it prevents the saddle from cutting into your legs or hips, allowing for longer periods of comfort without the need for frequent readjustment.

• Stretch Pleat:
  The Lonestar stretches to fit your body perfectly, making it feel like it was made just for you. This pleated design adapts to the user's build, creating a custom fit regardless of your body shape. This feature allows the saddle to flex and conform to your body, reducing the chances of discomfort, particularly when sitting in one position for hours.

• Hip Pinch Reduction System (HPRS):
  Some saddles can pinch your hips after sitting for a long time. The Lonestar’s design prevents this by ensuring the tension stays even across the saddle. Hip pinch is a common problem with many saddles, and this system redistributes tension, providing continuous support across your hips without creating pressure points that cause discomfort.

• Breathable Padding:
  Staying cool is important during warm-weather hunts. The Lonestar has padding that allows airflow and wicks away moisture, keeping you comfortable. This feature becomes even more important when hunting in warmer climates, where long hours in the saddle can become uncomfortable due to heat. The padding is designed to manage sweat and reduce overheating, allowing you to stay focused.

• Versatile Belt Options:
  The Lonestar comes with a metal-free rope belt, but you can easily switch to a standard buckle belt if you prefer. This versatility allows you to choose the belt that best fits your comfort and security needs, providing flexibility for different situations or preferences.

When to Use the Lonestar

Imagine settling into your spot at dawn, knowing you’ll be sitting there until sunset. The Lonestar’s comfort means you won’t be fidgeting or constantly shifting your weight. Its breathable padding keeps you cool, and the design prevents discomfort, allowing you to focus entirely on your surroundings. If your game requires patience and stillness, this saddle’s features ensure you’re not distracted by discomfort or heat.

Is the Lonestar Right for You?

• You stay in one spot for long periods and need maximum comfort.
• You want a saddle that’s simple to use without needing a lot of adjustments.
• You appreciate versatility, like being able to switch belts easily.

Comparing the Two Saddles

Both the Method 2 and the Lonestar have their strengths, so let’s compare them based on different scenarios.

If You Value Mobility:

The Method 2 is a great choice for hunters who move around a lot. Its compact design and quick setup make it easy to adjust your position throughout the day. It’s lightweight and won’t slow you down when you’re covering a lot of ground. The two-panel system and free-floating belt ensure that the saddle won’t impede your movement, whether you’re hiking to a new spot or climbing into the tree.

If You Value Comfort for Long Sits:

The Lonestar is ideal for hunters who stay put. Its extra support and breathable padding make it great for long hours in the tree. If you’re hunting in warm weather or need to stay still for extended periods, this saddle will keep you comfortable. The Cradle Chassis and HPRS are designed specifically for this type of hunting, giving you the support you need to stay focused on your target.

Things to Keep in Mind

For the Method 2:

• Learning Curve:
  The Method 2’s adjustability is fantastic, but it might take some practice to get the hang of all the features. If you're not used to making so many adjustments or customizing your gear, it could take a few outings to master the system and get your setup just right.

• Magnets:
  While the magnetic panel system is innovative, some hunters wonder if it will hold up in really tough weather conditions. Although magnets can be incredibly reliable, extreme environments (like very cold or very wet conditions) may require extra care.

For the Lonestar:

• Bulk:
  The extra comfort comes with a bit more weight and bulk, so it’s not as streamlined as the Method 2. If you're planning long hikes or need to minimize your load, the Lonestar might feel a bit heavier to carry. However, the added comfort often outweighs this slight drawback, particularly for long, stationary hunts.

• Less Customization:
  If you’re the type of hunter who likes to tweak every little detail, the Lonestar might feel a bit too straightforward for your tastes. It doesn’t offer the same level of micro-adjustability as the Method 2, but for many hunters, the simplicity translates to reliability and ease of use.

Making Your Decision

Still not sure which one to choose? Here are a few final questions to ask yourself:

• Do you move around a lot?
  If so, the Method 2’s lightweight, compact design will suit you better.

• Do you prefer to stay in one spot for long periods?
  If so, the Lonestar’s comfort is hard to beat.

• Do you like to customize your gear?
  The Method 2 offers more options for adjusting the fit.

• How important is comfort during long sits?
  If discomfort distracts you from the hunt, go with the Lonestar.

Final Thoughts: Enhancing Your Saddle Hunting Experience

At the end of the day, choosing between the Method 2 and the Lonestar isn’t about picking the "best" saddle. It’s about finding the one that fits your hunting style. Both saddles are high-quality, well-respected options, and either could be a great addition to your hunting gear.

If possible, try to get some hands-on experience with both. Visit an outdoor expo or local outfitter to see if you can try them out. Your choice will affect not only your comfort but also how effective you are in the field.

Take the time to think about your priorities, and choose the saddle that will make your next hunting trip the best one yet.